Post your "UNPOPULAR" Japanese music opinions! / aka "HOT TAKES" :P

Despa was also the first band I thought of when Zeus started this topic. Back then Diru, Gaze and Despa were the “Big 3” to me.

4 Likes

Jiluka needs more metalcore/metal fans tbh, it’s a bit sad and annoying when Ricko asks for a wall of death and some people are trying to split while others are staying put and not moving at all. This is only specific to overseas and not in Japan btw.

4 Likes

just curious, how do you feel the 2000s bands you’ve heard so far sound?

i got into vkei in the 2010s, so 2000s bands were established when i get to know them, and bands like Royz or Meji were the rookie startups at the time.

when i looked back at bands from the 90s, even tho i’ve come to love them now, they always sounded super thin and trebly to me, like weaker in sound and kinda easy to ignore.

ofc by now i know that decade’s full of legendary albums i love, but it makes me wonder if the decades since sound a certain strange way to someone who’s new to them!

1 Like

84 year old me and my walker will be there (edited because I can’t math)

4 Likes

2000-2009 bands i know, for reference: SID, deadman, lynch., baroque, MERRY, The GazettE, AN CAFE, DEATHGAZE, D, NoGoD, SuG, 9GOATS BLACK OUT, R-shitei, kein, ViViD, and Versailles

Thats all based on a chart i have saved they may be wrong. I feel like the 2000s was the biggest era of diversity with the sound of vkei artists.

In the 1990s and before, they did sound a bit weak, but I attribute that to the poorer recording quality of the time, as well as the natural progression of heaviness in music (compare 1960s rock to the metal of today)

And then, as vkei progressed, ive noticed the incorporation of western metalcore influences into artists’ sound (gulu gulu takes inspo from Korn, btw? I cant remember which member but someone in the band is a big fan of them), which has made them sound more similar to each other, and also newer bands will obviously take inspo from older bands and will sound similar. Ive always noticed that some of DADAROMA’s music has sounded A LOT like mejibray, anyone else? No shame to either band btw, because theyre two of my faves

However in the 2000s, there wasnt much of a western appeal and therefore less western influence, but also the genre was quickly evolving, sprouting new subgenres and developing old ones. Like two of my favorite 2000s bands, R-Shitei and SuG could not be any further from each other in sound, yet they existed in the same era

Idk what im trying to say, ig that the 2000s were mkre unique that other eras? Whatever

8 Likes

My unpopular take:

Yes, the AI trend is kind of crap. But it seems to be where more VK artists are turning to save some cash, so it’s just going to be one of those things like military uniforms and the occasional oofy tweet that people who follow VK as a whole just kind of have to…learn to compartmentalize. Or else you’re gonna have a bad time.

13 Likes

Most of the time they do not really safe money, tho. Most videos are still the typical ones were we mostly see the band in their costumes playing their instruments with some AI scenes added or AI effects. Making that same video without these snippets and effects would look better and cost less because they would not need the licence or (if they have) the dude who is working with the AI tool.

Let me give some examples:

Arlequin’s newest mv looks cheaper with the bad AI effects. Would have been a solid video with just the montain of chairs.

Deviloof made such a fantastic mv that even looks like high production value. The AI parts look so so bad compared to the real parts. Why ruin a video that you already put a good amount of money in with the cheap looking bits?

Did you notice how most AI use is always short bits? Because it’s relativly complicated to make longer consistent videos with AI. That would need human labour, which is expensive again.

Also the problem with vk bands is, they sell their image to the fans so the band has to be in most of the videos. So they have to buy costumes, put on make up and shoot these scenes anyway. That’s what costs most and they can’t really safe here.

I geniuly believe that they think they are saving money by adding “cool effects” for little money. But I don’t think their target audience ask for this or would buy less music if they didn’t use AI :sweat_smile: they are sold a product that they don’t need. At least not for this purpose. I guess nobody would bat an eye if they used it to create lyric videos.

DEG/Sukekiyo is a special case because they did spend more on it so it is a much bigger part off their video and they probably can use the positiv and negativ attention. But that attention comes from “us of AI” as a controversial topic not because the videos themselves looked particular good and I doubt they were that cheap.

In the end adding some AI scenes doesn’t really makes an unspired mv better. And if you really have some creative ideas you probably won’t need AI.

Either Ai will become much better and we won’t see the real bands anymore in the MVs or the trend will fade out when they have played around enough and get bored themselves.

Let me close with an example of an mv that I think is conveing the song pretty well and manages to create a certain atmosphere and probably did not cost that much, without using any AI.

16 Likes

I was thinking more along the lines of album art, tour poster art, merch designs, etc. The more that a band or label that is not artistically inclined can do to DIY designs that they would normally have to hire visual artists for, the more they’ll save in the long run even if the end result looks tacky.

And given that almost the only people who voice any displeasure with this trend are international fans, I doubt that the bands will change anything about what they’re doing.

3 Likes

late reply but ty for responding! i wouldn’t have personally guessed the 2000s would be known by bands’ diversity - but it’s cool to hear you say that, and come to think of it i’d definitely agree

there’s a few on that list i’ve still got to check out myself…

3 Likes

Absolutely! Theyre all good bands in their own ways and id recommend listening! I know i have a lot of catching up to do on bands i need to hear..

1 Like

I’m gonna be real here, I’m really tired of the AI talk.
Yeah I hate it and if some bandman on the street hands me a flyer with AI designs on it, I’m not gonna check his twitter out or whatever.

If a band I like uses AI for their merch, I just won’t buy the merch.
If a band I like uses AI backdrops during their lives, I’ll just stop going if it bothers me. (Yes it already happened once)
If a band I don’t care for uses AI backdrops, I won’t see them again.

If a band uses AI for their music videos…

Honestly, I think I’ve only watched 1 MV of my own accord within the past year, and that was because it was in a DVD that came with an EP.

The rest were PVs on the backdrops behind the stage at lives.

I listen to new releases on streaming and I barely ever look at whatever new PVs the bands are releasing. It’s been a really long time since I last saw a PV and it stuck in my head, so

I guess my hot take is that MVs are unnecessary now.

8 Likes

Tangentially related that’s been stuck in my head lately - we really should give Morrie/Dead End their flowers :folded_hands:

2 Likes

We need a band that mixes visual kei styles the same way Sleep Token mixes genres.

4 Likes

I’ve been giving lynch’s GALLOWS a listen for the first time after avoiding it for years, and it’s actually pretty good, despite maybe being the start of their “same song” era. Not nearly as bad as it was made out to be

5 Likes

IKR?! It is actually very good, even coming from someone who hates nothing :sob:

1 Like

Gallows is Life

2 Likes

Not exactly sure where this goes
but a fan harmed themselfs at a photoshoot at Senketsu event the other day and of course stan twitter is just “OH MY GOD WHY CAN’T THEY RESPECT THE BAND!” your talking about a band who vocalist is rumored to have acutal mental issues requiring meds and has at least 1 count of acutally hurting on stage and just yesteday I heard they have a fake harm furi dance

The band fan base is made of delusional mental issued teenagers internationally and I’m sure there are some in person they always see what Hiro does or say and go “aww, thats so cute! he gets me!! look I’m just like him he’s my hero”

I’m not saying it’s the band fault for what happened and I do truly hope that fan is okay but when you prompt those kinds of activities and don’t tell your fan base “hey, being para social isn’t okay!” something is bound to happen

6 Likes

I think this is about right. I like the band, and I enjoy their gimmick and the vocalist’s antics, but they’re a band that’s not even doing the whole thing of selling their theme as a cathartic release or a surrogate. It’s just blatant aesthetization of mental health issues and conciously playing the menhera ”wave” with no empowering messages, no nothing but misery. I’ve watched a few of the vocalist’s streams and he’s all about that life, quite transparently so, and I don’t think he ever expected in his wildest dreams to ”blow up” on foreign vk communities.

4 Likes

I am a very active member of vkeitwt and I agree. Alot of people will slam people like that fan even tho they aren’t much different. I feel like Senketsu themselves should have done something about it, but I suppose what is done is done. I wish the best for that fan and I hope it does not happen again with anyone else. That is why I like this community, vkeitwt is really infuriating sometimes with how much they spread false rumors and just the drama.

2 Likes

THANK YOU I thought I was seconds away from stans finding me with pitch forks lol

Yeah, I haven’t seen anything about the rest of the members it’s always just Hiro and I even talked to one of there stan’s recently she was the exact international type I thought there fans were which there nothing wrong with that it’s just…there is no line drawn with this band no “hey that’s too far”

like fake harming furi when your vocalist (Hiro) is rumored to have acutal dignosis mental issues and is on meds and I get it “make fun of your mental issues haha where all fked in the head one way or another!” but it gives me the ick when I know a member of said band has mental issues it

It would be different if it was a band like Hitchcock Karasu does that kind of stuff all the time but for Hitchcock it’s an acutal joke and Karasu knows it but with Senketsu I can’t ever tell what is and what is not a joke like he acutally brought a sharp object and did it on stage and when you don’t put up that line then you do draw in the people who look at that stuff and begin to idolise you and think that stuff is cool because you do it

2 Likes