What are the "big old three" in your opinion?

I don’t think it’s possible to simplify it to three, mainly because musically the scene is way too all over the place…

you can roughly sum the base of it all to X JAPAN, D’ERLANGER, DEAD END, BUCK-TICK, KUROYUME and LUNA SEA.

but just for the sake of the question, I’d say X, B-T and LS, as they probably covers the most ground possible, influence-wise

it is simply fucked up to leave morrie out, as he is the inspiration of EVERYONE, but oh well…

7 Likes

For me, overall, it’s L’Arc-en-Ciel, GLAY and Kuroyume. I think those three had the best balance of success, longevity and influence on the J-rock/VK scene. But I’m partial to the more pop side of VK, so there’s some of my own bias in there.

I think DIR EN GREY, MUCC and the GazettE would be good picks if we’re talking specifically about the overseas VK fandom, but I’d probably swap L’Arc in for MUCC since I think they’ve got a bit broader of a following because of their anime themes.

3 Likes

This user on note created a list of the bands from that vk genealogy television program I watched several years ago, and it seemed to check out for me (goes up to the 2010s.) You would just have to pick your three from each era:

Unrelated Supplementary Material

Subgenres, expanded '85-'99 history, and a top albums list?
ヴィジュアル系のサブジャンルを本気でまとめてみた|元カノの子供をテリヤキにして食べたい
https://90s-visual-kei-vk.themedia.jp/posts/13152652?categoryIds=1128061
ファン500人が選んだ「後世に伝えたい90年代ヴィジュアル系伝説の名盤」ベスト50 | GALLERY OF VISUAL SHOCK

1 Like

NUMBER GIRL, Eastern Youth, and Bloodthirsty Butchers

…oh wait, wrong forum!

9 Likes

DIMLIM, 8P-SB, Initial’L,

3 Likes

Maria, Kiwamu, Kisaki

4 Likes

This is dentist’s dreamy top-3

the real vk tree: https://x.com/vr_noru/status/1934884405077836284

2 Likes