I have some thoughts. I didn’t know if I wanted to post it here or in the review thread, but I chose here.
DIR EN GREY is a band that’s gone through a ton of sonic changes in their career as a band. They’ve constantly reinvented themselves from one album to the next and I believe a large part of that is by taking advantage of all the tones a guitar has to offer. What do I mean? Ever since the days of MACABRE, these guys have been experimenting with alternative tunings, amps, and guitar setups to achieve different sounds…but at some point that experimentation stopped and they seem to have settled on Drop D + A.
Let’s examine.
GAUZE - E Standard the whole way through (E A D G B E)
MACABRE - Mostly E Standard, although Hydra is implied to be in D Standard because the song is tabbed in the key of D Minor. (D G C F A D)
Official Score
Kisou - Absolutely all over the place.
- Kigan, FILTH, Mushi, Jessica, Pink Killer is D Standard.
- I’ve seen Zomboid tabbed in E Standard but I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s off.
- Keloid Milk is in C# with some guitar parts tabbed to (G# C# F# C# E G# D) which isn’t anything I recognize, but comes sort of close to the middle of 11-string standard tuning. I think it’s wrong but there’s no official score for this song so I can’t say.
- Domestic Fucker Family, Karasu is C# Standard (C# F# B E G# C#)
- undecided is tabbed as E Standard, but wouldn’t be surprised if the guitar is in D and the song is just in the key of E
- No one tabbed out 24 Cylinders, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s in D as well
Six Ugly -
- Mr. NEWSMAN is tabbed in Drop C# (C# G# C# F# A# D#) but I wouldn’t be surprised if the tabs are a half step off because everything else is in Drop D (D A D G B E)
VULGAR -
- audience killer LOOP, THE IIID EMPIRE, INCREASE BLUE, Kasumi, NEW AGE CULTURE, CHILD PREY is in Drop C#
- Shokubeni, RED…[em], Asunaki Koufuku…, MARMALADE CHAINSAW, R TO THE CORE, DRAIN AWAY, OBSCURE, and AMBER is tabbed as Drop D
- Sajou no Uta is tabbed as E Standard
Withering to death. -
- Merciless Cult, C, Saku, Kodoku ni Shisu…, GARBAGE, Machiavellism, dead tree, The Final, Spilled Milk, Kodou are all tabbed out as Drop C#
- Itoshisa wa Fuhai ni Tsuki and Higeki wa Mabuta wo Oroshita Yasashiki Utsu are tabbed as E Standard, although I’m not sure if that’s just the key and the guitars stay in C#.
- Beautiful Dirt is tabbed in Drop D, but I have my doubts.
- Jesus Christ R’ n R is tabbed in D Standard
THE MARROW OF A BONE - Drop C#.
UROBOROS -
- Ware Yami to te… is tabbed in Eb Standard (D# G# C# F# A# D#)
- Everything else tabbed as Drop C#
When they switch over to 7-strings is where my point starts coming together.
DUM SPIRO SPERO -
- Blossoming Beelzebub, Different Sense, Juuyoku, Shitataru Mourou, Lotus, DECAYED CROW, are Drop D + A (A D A D G B E)
- Amon, Akatsuki, Hageshisa…, Ruten no Tou, and Diabolos tabbed as A# Standard (A# D# G# C# F# A# D#) although I wonder if it’s really Drop D + A
- There’s a lot going on in Vanitas, but it looks like a mix of Drop D + A, 6-string Drop D, and even E Standard. But I’m gonna have to give it to Drop D + A because Toshiya is in A.
ARCHE - Mostly Drop D + A
- No one tabbed Magayasou, but I’m gonna assume it’s either Drop D + A or A# Standard.
- Tabs for Phenomenon assume 6-string, but I’m gonna assume Drop D + A for this as well.
- Tousei, Kaishun is tabbed as A# Standard
The Insulated World - Drop D + A
- No one tabbed Keibetsu to Hajimari, but I’m assuming it’s Drop D + A as well
The World of Mercy - No tabs, but I saw them live and they didn’t swap guitars, so I’m going Drop D + A
PHALARIS - Sparsely tabbed, but the songs that do exist are Drop D + A
The Devil in Me - Drop D + A.
See the pattern?
Ever since Dir en grey switched over to 7 string they’ve been almost exclusively locked in A. Specifically Drop D + A, but sometimes when they’re feeling spicy they bust out A# Standard. But since The Insulated World it’s been almost exclusively Drop D + A. They don’t go lower than this with the exception of Warsaw no Gensou, which is tabbed as Drop E in 7-string guitar but I have my suspicions it’s Drop E on 8-strings (E B E A D G B E).
I’m tired of this sound. I personally prefer Drop A on my 7-string (A E A D G B E) and you would think that changing D->E doesn’t make a big sonic difference, but it really does. Drop D + A sounds so muted and more low than heavy, which is why songs like the remade Rasetsukoku and OBSCURE do nothing for me (both in Drop D + A). I get why they run it (allows them to play most of their songs rather easily), but I’m also in the market for a new sound.
I wonder what their resistance is to go lower and into G# territory. Going lower doesn’t necessarily fix everything, but it opens up new chord voicings and opportunities for creativity. They can stay on 7’s and try out Russian Tuning, A Standard, G# Standard, Open C, etc.
Something other than this Drop D + A, please.