I was a big fan of Meji back in their day, first heard of them when Messiah was new!
#1 thing i remember is they were always being accused of ruining vkei, what’s wrong with vkei nowadays. Which i think was something they were aware of and purposefully cultivated.
I don’t think Tzk’s unaware of how his voice is and presents; opinion was he’s talentless and hard on the ears. Meto’s drums were mixed to be as boxy as possible, sounding faker and more unnatural than MIDI samples. This plus his nonspeaking doll persona led to constant opinion he’s not actually got any skill as a drummer. Koichi would do some of the same - look at Raven PV where he’s got those 6” nails acting like he’s playing a bass. MiA for all their PVs for at least half their career would forgo amps and instead bring an iMac with amp sims on the screen.
On the visuals, Meto would switch aggressively between onnagata, masculine, and nonhuman (eg plush bear costume?) presentation, not speaking all the while, making him hard to put in a box or role, which is what vkei usually does more than most music. Can’t remember which release this was but Koichi iirc did a whole artist shoot and PV with his head wrapped in gauze and markings on his face drawn as if he’d hopped off the operating table mid-facelift.
I don’t mean to give the impression i’m defending them from being cyber bullied hahah what i mean instead is they would consistently be choosing artistic directions most likely to get themselves criticized. They’d each provoke in their own category (eg back in the 2000s amp sims were for posers and if you used them instead of real amps you kept that a secret) leading to a notoriety not unlike Deviloof’s brief run of iconoclasms.
But compounding on this was their 12-mo consecutive release run, which (imho as amateur vkei historian) is The Thing that brought them from a strange band in their corner of vkei to maybe top 10 most representative of the scene.
Maybe this is a personal note but i recall Tsuzuku sharing on his Ameblo a diagnosis of BPD, which is referenced by name in one of his songs around that time. Afaik that’s pretty uncommon in vkei, transparency at that level! I think
If we’re being honest, i personally suspect every song credited to MiA is ghostwritten. They changed styles and ornamentations so quickly from one song to another, one single to another, and i don’t really feel like i hear much stylistic continuity or growth from one to another. But i’m not saying this as a criticism! They’re easily one of my favorite bands in vkei. I just see it as them (incl management) having a vision or idea of what they wanted the song to be and hiring someone who’d be the best to write that song. So the “420” theatrical roses (i swear that name + cover art are awful on purpose) ends up extremely tight and coherent as a result. I consider it their masterpiece, and there’s no way the last track wasn’t made in direct quotation of the last track of Lareine’s Fierte no Umi.
For the record i ALSO suspect all the tracks credited to Tsuzuku were actually written by him, bc they’re very similar in style, following similar sounds across years even when the rest of the single’s tracks don’t. And ngl i think every single track people complain about is a Tzk composition lmao
So add that all together and you get four guys who know vkei well, have a lot to say, cover a lot of ground quickly and consistently, while being just about maximally annoying and bothersome for twitter and tumblr to discuss endlessly, with music that’s absolutely good enough to back all the promo they’re doing. If you’re into that sorta sound, at least